How to Protect Your Main Domain's Reputation When Sending Cold Emails

Published on May 9, 2025 by Eric Bouchard

Sending cold emails is a powerful way to generate leads, but doing it wrong can quickly burn your main domain’s reputation. Once your primary domain is blacklisted, fixing it is a long, painful process and often not worth the hassle.

Luckily, there’s a smart workaround: use secondary domains for outreach and redirect them to your main site. This method allows you to preserve your brand’s reputation while still running effective cold email campaigns.

Why Protecting Your Main Domain Matters

• If your domain gets flagged or blacklisted, all emails from it may land in spam even for clients and partners.
• Your overall email deliverability can drop drastically across all platforms (Gmail, Outlook, etc.).
• Fixing domain reputation takes weeks or months, if it’s possible at all.

How to Use Multiple Domains the Right Way

The key isn’t just buying multiple domains it’s using them strategically:

1. Buy Similar Domains
   Get domains that are closely related to your main one (e.g., if your main domain is yourbrand.com, buy yourbrand.co or yourbrandmail.com).
2. Set Up Proper Email Authentication
   Configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records for each domain to build credibility with ISPs.
3. Warm Up the Domains
   Start slow don’t send 500 emails on day one. Gradually increase volume over weeks.
4. Redirect Secondary Domains to Your Main Site
   This builds trust. If someone checks the domain, they’ll land on your real website. Set up a 301 redirect or use DNS settings to forward traffic.
5. Use No More Than 100 Emails Per Domain Per Day
   This helps avoid triggering spam filters. Create separate inboxes per domain and rotate usage.

Things to Avoid

• Never send bulk emails from your main domain.
• Don’t skip domain authentication it’s a red flag for spam filters.
• Avoid using domains that don’t point to a real site it looks suspicious.
• Don't send hundreds of emails from a newly purchased domain. It will almost certainly get flagged.

Final Thoughts

If cold outreach is part of your strategy, don’t risk your main domain. By using properly set up secondary domains and redirecting them to your real site, you can safely scale your efforts without hurting your brand.

Want to simplify this process? Our platform handles domain setup, email warming, and cold email delivery using verified sending domains so you can focus on results, not reputation management.

Try our cold email platform free for 7 days